1997 Honor: A Girl Named Disaster

VERDICT: Treasure?

Laurinda’s Rating: 3.5/5

A Girl Named Disaster by Nancy Farmer was one of the 1997 Newbery Honor selections. It tells the story of Nhamo, a girl from Mozambique who ends up on many adventures. Nhamo lives in a traditional village; she is responsible for many onerous chores, like grinding grain and hauling water. After the village comes down with a plague, they visit a witch doctor. He opines that insufficient reparations for the murder committed by Nhamo’s father is the cause. In recompense, 11-year-old Nhamo is to marry a repulsive man.

Nhamo’s kind grandmother gives her a stash of gold nuggets, information about her father’s last location, and directions to Zimbabwe. Nhamo sets off in a boat, on a journey that should only take days. She gets lost and ends up having to survive in first one isolated location, then the next. Eventually, Nhamo makes it across the mined border. She lands at a research station, sick with many different illnesses. They locate her father’s family, although, because her father was both dead and a jerk, it’s not the joyous reunion Nhamo hoped for. She goes to live with them, learns to read,  which she loves, and learns much, but finds that her real family is in the research station.

I have mixed feelings about this book. It is HIGHLY descriptive, which is both a strength and a weakness. After a while, I just wanted the author to get on with the plot, rather than meticulously running us through all the actions Nhamo takes to survive when isolated. However, the description did a strong job of painting the scene. I also appreciated that the author described Nhamo’s inner life along with her external one. So, we got to see when Nhamo was achingly lonely, scared, etc.

As someone with a background in anthropology, I found the mix of cultures interesting, too. Nhamo depends on many traditional skills and beliefs to survive after she leaves her village, but it is that very culture that forces her departure. Similarly, we see some of the evils of modern civilization, like areas that have a ton of land mines and foreigners who set dogs on Nhamo just for looking through their window. But, the research station epitomizes the search for the new, and those are the skills and people Nhamo comes to treasure most.

I’d recommend this for late elementary or middle school children looking for a book with a strong female main character. It might especially appeal to those who like adventures and a level of detail often found in narrative non-fiction. In some ways, it reads like a modern Swiss Family Robinson, in that it’s a tale of survival in the wild.




2014 Honor – Doll Bones

VERDICT: Treasure

Laurinda’s Rating: 4.5/5

Doll Bones by Holly Black, a 2014 Newbery Honor winner, is a story about stories, about growing up, and about one creepy doll. Alice, Poppy, and Zach have been playing together for a long time. Using a variety of action figures and dolls, they create their own stories. On the brink of adolescence, Zach’s dad feels that dolls aren’t manly, and throws out all of Zach’s figures. This precipitates changes in the friends’ relationship. It also causes Poppy to pull The Queen, an antique bone china doll, out of the case in which it is typically displayed.

And then, The Queen appears in Poppy’s dreams, telling her that the doll is made of a young woman’s bones, bones that must be laid to rest. Poppy talks Alice and Zach into undertaking a real life quest. Without parental permission, they buy bus tickets to the city in which the doll was made, and set off on a quest of their own. Like any good heroes, they face various obstacles along the way. They don’t always meet them with grace, but they do overcome them eventually. They succeed in their quest, and in hashing out a way forward in lives that dawning adolescence was making unfamiliar.

I listened to this as an audio book and really enjoyed it. There aren’t any jump scares, just some of the usual creepiness of dolls – eyes open when they shouldn’t be, clearly cremains inside the doll body, adults around them thinking they were a party of 4 when only 3 actual children existed, etc. The author balances adventure with the hard work of preteens negotiating relationships between each other in a way that children don’t do as self-consciously. She also integrates the store of Eleanor (the girl whose bones were used in the making of the doll), revealing that story piece by piece, with information integrated as a method for moving the plot along.

As a librarian,  I was also amused, and appreciative, of the author making the librarian VERY non-stereotypical. She also showed some of the realities of dying towns – kids were upset that the library was closed on the weekend, librarian found them because she was coming in to do selection and ordering when the library was closed, etc.

Late elementary school and middle school is the target audience, with some complexities to the relationship stuff that might skew it more towards the middle school side, just because kids a bit older have started to deal with those issues in their own lives.

2017: The Girl Who Drank the Moon

VERDICT: Meh. Treasure….ish?

Laurinda’s Rating: 3.5/5

I read this book about six months ago. I was so meh about it that the review has sat half finished since then. The Good: The plot is original and plays with some of the common tropes of fairytales, like “wicked” witches and monsters in the woods. It features strong, multi-faceted female characters, who do their own rescuing. There are Magic and Monsters and Good vs. Evil. The Bad: The style is awkward. It speaks pseudo fairytalese, but doesn’t quite commit. It also shifts between characters a bit to frequently. I found myself skimming the last hundred or so pages, hoping desperately that the book would FINALLY end.

Overall, give this is a try if you like fantasy or fairytales. Just because I didn’t love it, doesn’t mean you won’t!


2016 Honor: Roller Girl (they see me rollin, they hatin)

VERDICT: Treasure!

Laurinda’s Rating: 5/5

Roller Girl is the story of a girl who decides to sign up for roller derby camp. Astrid sees a flyer and decides to go for it. Her friend Nicole opts for dance class instead, though Astrid tells her mom that Nicole is doing roller derby with her. Classes are hard; Astrid is the only total beginner. However, she keeps with it, encouraged by anonymous correspondence with one of the women from the local roller derby team. Astrid gains in skills and confidence.

Along the way, Astrid makes new friends, but is also forced to realize that sometimes old friends grow apart. There is an incident with a soda and Nicole’s new friend. Astrid’s hard work on both roller derby and her friendships culminates in her playing in her first roller derby bout.

The illustrations are gorgeous and the main character extremely charming. Every person who has felt odd or different will relate to this book. This is one of my favorite Newbery books ever. Astrid isn’t perfect, but she makes some tough choices; the relationships presented in the book, similarly, aren’t perfect, but ring true because of that.

1984 Honor: A Solitary Blue (Heron, or Boy)


Laurinda’s Rating: 3/5

A Solitary Blue, one of the 1984 Newbery Honor selections, is set in the same universe as Voigt’s Dicey’s Song, the 1983 Newbery Medal Winner, reviewed by Sally and I. It follows Jeffrey from roughly ages 6-17. A Solitary Blue focuses heavily on relationships and emotions. When Jeff is in early elementary school, his vivacious mother Melody, always involved superficially in a cause, walks out for the final time, leaving Jeff with his very reserved father. Jeff always calls his father The Professor. Jeff decides that homeostasis is the way to go, so as he grows up, he increasingly takes on the task of keeping everything neat and orderly for The Professor.

When Jeff is in middle school, he comes down with a bad case of pneumonia. His father doesn’t initially realise he is sick; it takes the intervention of kind family freed Brother Brian to knock The Professor out of his shell. The illness also leads to renewed contact between Melody and the family she left behind, including an invitation for Jeff to spend the summer with her in Charleston.

The first summer Jeff spends in Charleston is freeing. His emotional mother helps him express himself fully. Jeff is immersed in the luxury which his extended family’s income affords them, while still having the freedom to go exploring the city. The transition back to life with his reserved father is challenging. With the memory of the first summer, Jeff has high hopes for another one. However, things are much different. His mother is dismissive of him or away with her boyfriend much of the time, his older relatives are hateful, and the experience is unpleasant. On one of the last nights Jeff has there, he has a knockdown fight in which his mother verbally destroys him, to which he responds somewhat in kind. Jeff is overwrought and takes the boat he purchased earlier in the summer out to an island he had been exploring. He finally finds a bit of solace in a solitary blue heron.

Life isn’t much better when he gets home, as he feels incredibly betrayed by his mother; he takes to skipping school. This actually provides an opening for a growing relationship with his father once The Professor discovers what’s going on; the two bond over mutual hurt. At his dad’s suggestion, the two look for a new house and find a lovely cabin, sealed with the presence of a blue heron.

Although not always easy – his mother claims she’s going to sue for custody when his parent’s divorce is finalized, for example – Jeff makes friends in his new home, including with the Tillerman family from Dicey’s Song. It comes as a surprise to Jeff when his great grandmother leaves him the estate. He chooses to keep her engagement ring but pass the rest along to the former household staff. His final interaction with his capricious and manipulative mother is when she arrives asking about the ring. To be quits of her, he trades rings with her, keeping the one that is tied to family history while allowing her the monetarily valuable one.

This is not an easy book to read. I basically alternated which parent I wanted to scream at initially. My heart broke for Jeff at times, particularly when his mother deliberately attempted to manipulate him. It deals a lot with emotions and relationships and less so with action. The author’s character development keeps it from being a complete snore, but it’s still a pretty angsty book. I went through a phase when I was in middle school when this over-the-top angst might have appealed. As an adult, it was a bit much. However, I appreciated the book for dealing with some of the hard parts of both severing and establishing relationships, as well as the author’s lovely description of the natural beauty which soothed Jeff’s soul. It’s not bad, but neither do I recommend it highly.

1958 Honor: The Great Wheel (with not-so-great characters)


Laurinda’s Rating: 2/5

The Great Wheel by Robert Lawson was one of the 1958 Newbery Honor recipients. God knows why. More on that later.

Conn sets out from Ireland bound for his Uncle Michael’s New York business. On the voyage, he meets Trudy, a lovely German girl bound for Wisconsin. In NYC, Conn quickly learns the business of digging sewers and becomes his uncle’s right hand man. However, Aunt Honora had predicted that Conn would travel west and ride a great wheel. Enter Uncle Patrick, who hires Conn to work on a project Mr. Ferris is creating for the Chicago World’s Fair. Conn moves west and helps with every phase of construction of the first Ferris Wheel, a now familiar staple of fairs and carnivals. He also dreams of meeting Trudy there and writes her letters (which he can’t mail since he didn’t get her last name). Lo, during the last week of the fair, Trudy arrives! A shocker, I know. Conn gets hung up over Trudy’s family money, so it takes the pair until the last day of the fair to sort out their differences. They marry and move to Wisconsin to raise fat, happy cows and children.

The Good: If you’ve ever wondered how a Ferris Wheel is built, this is the perfect book for you. It goes into a fair amount of detail (way more than I cared about, for sure) on each stage of the construction. The illustrations are also excellent.

The Bad: Pacing is uneven and the character development is minimal. Secondary characters are caricatures built on stereotypes, lashed together with racial or ethnic epithets.

The Ugly: This book is BRIMMING with objectionable names. Every minor character’s nationality/group is mentioned before each appearance, and generally tagged with slang like mick, box head, etc. I realize some of this appears worse in hindsight than it would in its own context, but it’s still jarring. Sexism also runs rampant, highlighted in passages like this.

I’d conditionally recommend this for late elementary/early middle schoolers with a strong interest in engineering or construction. Beyond that, this book is better left forgotten.

1997 Honor: Ella Enchanted

VERDICT: Treasure

Laurinda’s Rating: 4/5

Ella Enchanted was one of the 1997 Newbery Honor books. Written by Gail Carson Levine, it is a riff on the familiar Cinderella story. Ella is “blessed” with obedience by a fairy who attended her christening. She is forced to follow any command given to her. While her mother is alive, this is a mildly annoying burden; Ella develops a strong will and a quick wit to escape through loopholes. However, after her mother dies, her father sends Ella off to finishing school with the daughters of a woman who will be Ella’s stepmother.

Hattie, one of the wicked stepdaughters, figures out Ella’s curse and uses it to torment her. After Ella is ordered to break a friendship with the only other girl at school who understands her, Ella runs away. Adventures ensue. Ella is captured by ogres and uses her knowledge of their language to turn their powers against them; refreshingly, Ella’s friend Prince Char and his knights arrive only after Ella has the situation well in hand. Ella proceeds to a giant’s wedding in the hopes of convincing Lucinda, the fairy who set the curse, to remove it. She is unsuccessful, but meets up with her father. Shortly thereafter, he remarries and Ella is forced into servitude.

Ella understands that the kingdom would be unsafe if she gave in to Prince Char’s wish that she marry him, so she fabricates a letter from Hattie saying that Ella ran away to marry a rich man. However, Ella can’t resist attending Prince Char’s homecoming balls; they fall in love all over again. The strain of her stepsister’s commands warring with Char’s love eventually allows Ella to break the spell, whereupon she marries Char.

This book was one of my all time favorites as a child. I read it over and over and over (what? I’m an obsessive rereader of my favorite books). It’s still entertaining as an adult. I know it will never happen, but I would love to see the author rewrite this as a more fully realized YA novel rather than a kid’s book. Both the world building and the character development fit the scope quite well, but leave me wondering about other details of the world and of the characters.

I highly recommend this to mid elementary school to early middle school readers who enjoy a story where the princess rescues herself. The blend of action and well developed characters, both primary and secondary, keep the reader’s attention and make this a fast read.